Students Could Wave Goodbye to Merit–Based Federal Aid

Student Loan Girl — Thu, 25 Jun 2009 16:41:00 GMT

In another move to restructure the federal financial aid system, President Obama has proposed ending the government’s five-year foray into merit-based student aid and redirecting those financial aid funds to the need-based Pell Grant program, reports The Chronicle of Higher Education (“An Experiment in Merit-Based Student Aid Is Likely to End,” June 26, 2009).

The Academic Competitiveness Grant and the National Science and Mathematics Access to Retain Talent Grant programs were created by Congress in 2006 to encourage students to take academically “rigorous” coursework in high school and then choose college majors in fields with labor shortages.

Only students who are eligible for need-based Pell Grants can qualify for the Academic Competitiveness Grants, which provide $750 and $1,300 to college freshmen and sophomores respectively, and for the SMART grants, which provide $4,000 to college juniors and seniors who major in science, math, and certain foreign languages.

But so far both grant programs have fallen short of their participation projections, due in large part to the Department of Education’s failure to promote the programs, as reported by the department’s own inspector general in 2008.

The other major problem has been the programs’ vague qualification criteria, which has made it difficult for financial aid officers’ to determine award recipients. The American Council on Education, in a 2006 letter to the Department of Education, called the grant program’s guidelines “unworkable” and defined them as placing a “breathtaking administrative burden” on colleges’ financial aid officers.

Obama’s Proposal Receives Support From Education Officials

Education Department officials support the president’s proposal to make the Pell program an entitlement with annual increases tied to inflation and to raise the maximum Pell awards by $200 to $5,500 by the 2010–11 academic year because, they say, the Pell Grant program better serves low-income students than the competitiveness grant programs.

This proposal “would benefit the vast majority of the nearly six million Pell Grant recipients worldwide,” even though the annual increases amount to significantly less funding for the one in 10 students who qualify for the Academic Competitiveness and SMART grants.

Even former Secretary of Education Margaret Spellings, who crafted the merit-based programs under the Bush administration, backs the proposal.

“Do higher education officials and K-12 officials prefer free money with no strings attached? Absolutely,” Spellings said. “But if we’re trying to move the needle, putting resources behind our policy goals is a more powerful and prudent way to go."

Share this post: email this | del.icio.us | reddit

Despite Down Economy, College Student Aid Still Thriving

Student Loan Girl — Tue, 24 Mar 2009 00:18:00 GMT

In economic downturns, colleges and universities become flooded with students of all ages looking to better prepare themselves for an increasingly competitive job market. But these schools haven’t been immune to the effects of today’s recession.

Fortunately, for every recent economic downturn in higher education — tuition hikes, state budget cuts, scholarship and grant cutbacks, and a fluctuating student loan market — there’s also been a tangible upside (“Glimmer of Hope for Student Aid in a Bad Economy,” USA Today, March 19, 2009).

Tuition Assistance

Downside: Public colleges have increased tuition by 4 percent per year over the past 10 years, and many schools are set to bump up tuition even more this year as they face unprecedented state budget cuts.

Upside: Federal stimulus money should help some public colleges to better cope with the loss of state funding and to minimize any increases in tuition. The state of Maryland is hoping to go a fourth-straight year without in-state tuition increases. Other colleges are offering one-time deals to students; Kent State University in Ohio is offering laid-off workers a one-time tuition and application waiver at its Trumbull campus, and Manchester College in Georgia is offering to refund one year of tuition for students who aren’t able to secure a job or admission to grad school within six months after graduation.

Institutional Aid

Downside: Trouble in the stock market has caused colleges’ endowments to drop 25 percent in value this year, which has severely hampered schools’ ability to offer scholarships.

Upside: Despite their endowment losses, more than 90 percent of the nation’s private colleges and universities will be increasing financial aid next year by 9.8 percent to make up for 4-percent tuition increases, according to the National Association of Independent Colleges and Universities.

Government Grants

Downside: Aid for merit scholarships has taken one of the biggest hits this year, primarily due to state budget cuts.

Upside: The federal stimulus package has increased the maximum award for Pell Grants — federal financial aid for low-income students — from $4,731 to $5,350 for the coming academic year and to $5,500 for the 2010–2011 academic year. And, an additional 800,000 students are expected to receive Pell Grant funding this year.

Federal Student Loan Programs

Downside: The $50 billion Federal Family Education Loan Program — the government program that provides federal student loans to more than 10 million students through third-party lenders — has been the larger of the two federal student loan programs. But over the past two years, the FFEL program has lost business to the Direct Loan Program, the government’s other federal student loan program through which the U.S. Department of Education provides federal student loans directly to families, as hundreds of cash-strapped FFELP lenders have been forced to exit the program.

Upside: The FFEL program has still managed to increase its student loan volume this year, and some lenders are returning to the student loan market now that the federal government has bought nearly $25 billion in lenders’ student loan securities, providing them with the capital to make new loans. The Direct Loan Program has picked up the slack, providing an additional $7 billion in lending this year.

Private Student Loans

Downside: The overall supply of capital for private student loans is estimated to have decreased by one-third — a decrease of between $6 billion and $7 billion — due in large part to the fact that lenders have made it harder for families to qualify for private student loans.

Upside: Increased government funding for federal Stafford student loans has helped to reduce students’ reliance on private student loans. And more students are maxing out their federal financial aid before turning to private student loans, which the USA Today suggests has helped students avoid over-borrowing in private student loans.

Share this post: email this | del.icio.us | reddit

Student Loan Blog : merit aid

Students Could Wave Goodbye to Merit–Based Federal Aid

Despite Down Economy, College Student Aid Still Thriving