Cost of College Continues to Climb, Even in a Recession
Even as the recession has depressed consumer prices and the cost of living has fallen over the last year, college tuition rose in 2009, with the largest percentage increases coming at community colleges and public four-year schools — the mounting expense of an education revealed in the College Board’s latest reports on financial aid and the cost of college, released yesterday (“Trends in Student Aid 2009” and “Trends in College Pricing 2009”).
Squeezed by state budget cuts, public colleges and universities have found themselves forced to raise tuition prices. Tuition and fees at public four-year institutions rose by 6.5 percent for in-state students, to an average of $7,020 in the 2009–10 school year from $6,591 in 2008–09, and by 6.2 percent for out-of-state students, to $18,548 from $17,460.
The rise in community college tuition, to $2,544 this year from $2,372, although only a little shy of $200, represented the sharpest increase percentage-wise, a jump of 7.3 percent.
Costs at private four-year universities also crept upward, although at a slower rate of 4.4 percent, to $26,273 from $25,177.
“Given the financial hardship of the country, it’s simply astonishing that colleges and universities would have this kind of increases,” said Patrick Callan, president of the National Center for Public Policy and Higher Education. “It tells you that higher education is still a seller’s market” (“College Costs Keep Rising, Report Says,” The New York Times, Oct. 20, 2009).
Noting that the high school graduating class of 2009 was the largest in history, Callan went on, “Colleges and universities are capitalizing on that more than any other institution in the economy. If you walk around a shopping mall, nobody else is raising prices at the same rate” (“College: More Expensive Than Ever,” CNN Money, Oct. 20, 2009).
The Impact of Financial Aid
Only about a third of students pay these published “sticker” prices, however, underscored Sandy Baum, a senior policy analyst for the College Board and author of the two reports. Most students’ actual out-of-pocket costs are thousands of dollars lower because they receive some type of financial aid in the form of scholarships, grants, and student loans.
“If you look at net prices students pay, considering the grant aid and tax benefits, students at public two-year institutions are actually paying less, in inflation-adjusted dollars,” Baum pointed out. “Even though the sticker price, adjusting for inflation, is up 20 percent in the past five years, the net price is actually lower than it was five years ago.”
Net prices are also down at both public and private four-year universities.
Student Loans Still on the Rise
This drop in out-of-pocket costs notwithstanding, the gap between families’ available resources and the overall cost of attending college remains on a steady incline. Grant funding hasn’t kept up with the hikes in college costs, leaving students in a position of having to take out ever-larger amounts of money in student loans, particularly in the current economic climate, as more families struggle with unemployment, stagnant wages, and curtailed sources of credit.
“There’s a certain cruelty to a rise in education costs amid an economic slump,” observes Randy James, in a piece for TIME. “It makes the single most effective tool to help the underemployed and jobless out of their rut become all the more unreachable” (“The Incredible Climbing Cost of College,” Oct. 21, 2009).
Total education borrower increased by 5 percent from 2007–08 to 2008–09, the latest year for which student aid data are available. The volume of federal student loans — Stafford loans, Grad PLUS loans, and parent PLUS loans — grew by $14.7 billion last year.
“The level of debt we’re asking people to undertake is unsustainable,” said Callan.
In one bright note for student debt watchdog groups, this surge in federal college loans was accompanied by a sharp decline in nonfederal education loans. Nonfederal private student loans tend to have less flexible repayment terms, typically carry higher interest rates, and are generally more costly than federal student loans.
The volume of private student loans shrunk by half last year, to $11.9 billion.